Chapter 3
Chapter 3: Origin Story
Chapter 3: The Briefing
They meet again on Wednesday, four days before the drive up.
Same coffee shop, same corner table. This time Nadia is there first, which she can tell surprises him—he pauses when he sees her already seated, then adjusts without comment and sits down across from her. His coffee appears in thirty seconds. He must order it some other way, some system she hasn't decoded yet.
"Origin story," she says, skipping the preamble, because they only have an hour and there's a lot to cover. "Your family's going to ask. We need something that actually holds up."
"I've been thinking about that."
"You've been thinking about everything, so that doesn't narrow it down."
He sets his phone on the table but doesn't pick up his coffee yet. It's a tell she's catalogued recently—he doesn't drink when he's organizing a thought. "The Midwest Hospitality Summit. Last spring. You were coordinating the keynote session. I was attending a finance track panel."
Nadia looked up from her notebook. "That was seven months ago."
"Yes. You were managing a setup issue near the back of the main hall. Someone's AV connection had gone wrong and you were fixing it without drawing attention to it while simultaneously directing the registration staff through an earpiece. I walked past and spilled coffee on my sleeve. You noticed before I did."
She didn't remember him. She remembered the AV situation. She remembered fixing it in approximately ninety seconds while telling herself it was fine. She did not remember a man in a suit at the edge of her peripheral vision.
"You got me paper towels from the service station," he continued. "I thanked you. You asked if the coffee was hot enough to stain permanently. I said probably. You recommended OxiClean. You smiled like that was the funniest solution you'd ever had to offer."
Nadia's coffee cup paused halfway to her lips.
"So that's the beginning," he said. "Then we intersected at the company gala in February. Then again in April, when you came to brief the finance team on the annual retreat details. Over time, we talked. It became something."
"You don't talk," Nadia said. "Not at company events. I've seen you at three of them. You circulate twice, shake hands, and disappear to the side wall."
"I was preparing," he said. "The fake engagement requires a foundation that predates it."
She wrote spring summit — coffee — OxiClean in her notebook. "When did we start dating?"
"Two months ago. June."
"That's recent."
"My mother's health." He said it simply, without performance. "Chronic condition, new diagnosis. She wanted the family together. When I mentioned I was seeing someone seriously, she wanted to meet you. I wanted her to meet you. But I also wanted time before an engagement announcement."
"Let me guess—your mother accelerated the timeline."
"She has a way of making timelines feel inevitable."
Nadia filed that away. She could read between it clearly enough: a man trying to show up with something that proved he was fine. That he was living. She understood the instinct more than she wanted to admit.
"Okay," she said. "Two months, started seriously in June. That's plausible. Enough time to seem real, not so much that the absence of mention becomes suspicious." She looked at him. "How did you propose?"
Something shifted in the quality of the silence. He picked up his coffee.
"Late," he said. "Near midnight. Your apartment building has a rooftop access. I had the ring. You were surprised, even though we'd talked about marriage in general terms already. No audience. Just the city."
It was accurate to her in a way that should not have been possible. The rooftop she went to when she needed to think. The preference for late night over early morning. The fact that she would have found a staged public proposal intolerable but a private one—one that knew her well enough to skip the audience—could have made her cry.
"And I cried," she said.
"You don't usually cry in public."
"I would have. If someone who actually knew me proposed in the way someone who knew me would do it."
She heard the sentence after she'd said it and didn't take it back.
James set his coffee down. "The ring is my grandmother's. White gold, vintage setting. Pearl, not a diamond. She had strong opinions about traditional stones."
"She?"
"My grandmother." He paused. "And presumably you."
Nadia had strong opinions about traditional stones. She had spent twenty minutes in a jewelry museum gift shop once, unable to stop looking at a Victorian ring with a pale oval stone that didn't perform its value, just held it. She didn't remember mentioning this to anyone.
"Your family will believe that story?" she asked.
"They'll expect it. She's been asking me to marry since I was twenty-five. My grandmother. She would have wanted the ring used."
Nadia absorbed this—the image of James being told for years to settle down, to use the ring, to let someone in. It made him suddenly more dimensional. Less a CFO and more a man who'd been carrying his grandmother's ring around in a filing cabinet somewhere, waiting for a good reason to take it out.
She smiled, involuntarily.
He registered it. His eyes moved to her face with the particular attention he had—not intrusive, just thorough, like he was committing something to memory.
"Stop that," she said.
"I'm not doing anything."
"You're cataloguing again."
"I'm listening," he said. "There's a difference."
She turned back to her notebook. They had the origin story, the timeline, the proposal. What remained was the texture—the small details that would come up naturally, the things families asked. She wrote a question in the margin: What do I know about you that nobody else at work would know?
She read it to him.
He thought for a moment. "I run early in the morning. Before five. I don't like music in the office even though I listen constantly at home. I can't sleep in complete darkness—there has to be light under a door or through a gap in curtains. I read in the bathtub because it's the only room in my apartment where my phone doesn't feel urgent."
Nadia wrote all of it down.
"Your turn," he said.
She didn't look up from the notebook. "You already know mine."
"Tell me anyway."
She thought about how much to give him. Then she thought that they were doing this so convincingly that she'd find her own cover story believable, which meant she needed to actually practice saying true things out loud.
"I cook when I'm anxious," she said. "Specifically things that take a long time. Bread. Slow-cooked things. Anything that makes me wait." She kept writing as she talked. "I hate the moment before any event starts more than anything else about my job, but I love the two-hour mark, when you know it's working. I've never told anyone my real opinion of their event space unless they specifically asked and I was sure they could handle it."
"And if they can't handle it?"
"Then I rearrange the furniture when their back is turned and tell them the room had better flow this way."
Something close to a smile crossed his face. "That's very you."
"I know."
She capped the pen. The coffee shop had filled up around them—the lunch crowd beginning to gather, conversations layering over each other. She needed to get back to the office for a two o'clock.
"I think we have enough," she said.
"One more thing."
She looked at him.
"What's your favorite color?"
The question landed simply. She already knew what he would say. She'd known since Saturday, when she'd read the folder and understood the kind of attention he paid. She wanted to hear him say it anyway.
"Go ahead," she said. "Tell me."
He didn't hesitate. "Teal."
Nadia's hand tightened on the coffee cup. "How."
"Your office. Three prints on the wall. One is an ocean photograph in teal. One is a botanical print with teal accents. Your desk blotter is teal. Your bookmark is teal. You don't decorate that way unless the color means something."
She stared at him.
"It's a reasonable inference," he said, with the tone of someone who knows a thing is more than reasonable and is being tactful about it.
She gathered her notebook and her bag. She said, "I'll see you Friday morning." She walked to the counter, bought a pastry she didn't particularly want, and stood at the end of the bar while they boxed it.
Behind her, she heard James's voice. Low, unhurried. He'd answered his phone.
"—already handled. She's exactly what I told you she'd be."
The paper bag landed softly in her hand. She did not turn around.
You might also like




